PDA

View Full Version : Intriguing Reply From Whipple




LS2 GTO
07-30-2004, 11:45 PM
I sent them an email asking if they were considering a kit for the LS2 engine, their reply was: "WE DO NOT HAVE ANYTHING IN PRODUCTION RIGHT NOW FOR IT.IT IS RUMORED THAT THE GTO WILL COME FACTORY SUPERCHARGED IN THE NEAR FUTURE.THANK YOU." Has anyone else heard this before because I havent. :confused:




Odin
07-31-2004, 12:19 AM
hmm 2005 6.0 ls2 500hp Supercharged GTO judge? perhaps :hail:

GMH GTO
07-31-2004, 12:48 AM
Judge maybe, they were just pulling your chain. Future Supercharged GTO would have had its beans spilt here already.

Dbluegoat
07-31-2004, 04:08 AM
maybe they were speaking of something beyond '05

DevilYellow
07-31-2004, 04:40 AM
I call BS. GM wouldnt put one on an LS1 or LS2, they might but it on a truck motor with a lower compression ratio. Anyways, If they did supercharge a motor they would most likely use an eaton blower. Whipple would be all over that. The big dawg upgrade for 03/04 cobras is a KB or a Whipple.

nikivee
07-31-2004, 06:26 AM
Don't buy that at all.

Adam4356
07-31-2004, 07:42 AM
I'm not buying that either, but it is possible. Doesn't seem like a power play GM needs to make though. Going after the Cobra with a blower, forged internals, etc would absolutely net one of the sickest cars on the street today. GM has put alot of effort into NA motors and the LS2 at 400hp is very stout, so much so that it practically matchs the underrated 03 Cobra motor that needed a mess of cams, valves, and boost to make those numbers. Now if we consider a Z06 of the new C6 with more than 400hp, maybe something in the neighborhood of 450-500 that motor could easily find duty in the GTO (Judge ?). Still not FI and making sick power :hail:

Now i prefer NA power, but i can see a big group of GM guys from Silverado SS owners, SSR, GTO, and of course the new Camaro wanting a FI model for the shear ease and cost of modding, such as the 03 Cobra.

So it could, but likely won't happen. Consider that for about 5 years test production cars with the LS1 have ran around with blowers such as the Vette (tigershark). I remember a blown Escalade (not LS1), Transam, Sunfire, Cavalier too.

NBS4
07-31-2004, 11:08 AM
I'm not buying that either, but it is possible. Doesn't seem like a power play GM needs to make though. Going after the Cobra with a blower, forged internals, etc would absolutely net one of the sickest cars on the street today. GM has put alot of effort into NA motors and the LS2 at 400hp is very stout, so much so that it practically matchs the underrated 03 Cobra motor that needed a mess of cams, valves, and boost to make those numbers. Now if we consider a Z06 of the new C6 with more than 400hp, maybe something in the neighborhood of 450-500 that motor could easily find duty in the GTO (Judge ?). Still not FI and making sick power :hail:
.

You seem to forget the Cobra motor is only 4.6L where the LS2 is at 6L's. If the Cobra motor was the Same displacement as the LS2.. It would have 600 horsepower. You cannot compare the F/I Cobra Motor to the N/A LS2.

As for the 4V DOHC vs. The Pushrod Setup. Give me 4 Valves and 4 Cams anytime over the old Pushrod Design.

What's so wrong with F/I Power? LS Series Owners wish they had my low end torque and my built block.

miamio
07-31-2004, 11:19 AM
What's so wrong with F/I Power? LS Series Owners wish they had my low end torque and my built block.

I'm an LS series owner and I don't wish for any part of the mustang

NBS4
07-31-2004, 11:56 AM
I'm an LS series owner and I don't wish for any part of the mustang

Then You're a fool blinded by brand loyalty.

phobos512
07-31-2004, 01:18 PM
Then You're a fool blinded by brand loyalty.

I would watch what you say. You could be called a fool blinded by brand loyalty as well. The fact is, people buy what they like. This isn't communist Russia where everyone drives the same black motorcycle engined sedan. We buy our cars based on what we like about them. Some people like GMs. Some people like Fords. Some people like NA. Some people like FI.

Live and let live.

My first vehicle was a Ford Explorer. I then owned a Chrysler 300M Special. Now I own a Pontiac GTO. I learned to drive in my parents two Toyotas (Camry and 4Runner). No brand loyalty here, I just buy what I like at the time. :)

miamio
07-31-2004, 02:44 PM
None here either, I have an '88 t-bird turbo coupe and love that car maybe even a little more then my GTO.

Adam4356
07-31-2004, 04:01 PM
Well, DOHC vs. pushrod. Let's consider these equations.....


multiple small valves vs. bigger valve = same

displacement vs. positive displacement FI = same


There is no reason to want multivalve, DOHC other than a expensive, modding nightmare. I love how people believe they have some technological wonder in multivalve, DOHC motors. Consider a pushrod motor which is lighter, easier to work on, cheaper to manufacturer in bulk, and gets great gas mileage. Not to mention it can be put in ridiculously small engine bays while bringing huge displacement numbers.


As for why FI is not for everyone. The real talent in motor design is NA power, with emissions legality, and gas mileage. You can boost anything but i respect raw hp more. Just IMO.

2edybrd
08-01-2004, 06:21 AM
It's not really important whether or not one car has a factory blower or one car has a 346 or a 6 liter. Are they both fast as hell? Do they both get over 25 mpg on the highway? They do? Well...that's good enough for me.

And you are comparing apples to apples. See above for my reasoning. Even if the car is an 80000 USD XJR or a Silverado pick-up lowered and blown to 600 horsepower is irrelevent. They are both PERFORMANCE vehicles that do compete against each other where ever they happen to meet up.

Now if you where trying argue the off-road capabilities of the Corvette versus the Defender 90, you would have a pretty legitimate apples to oranges argument.

That's all I have to say about that.

stonebreaker
08-03-2004, 09:57 AM
There are a few places in Australia that are just now experimenting with an LSx supercharger kit using a twin screw Whipple-type blower. The one guy I got an email from priced his 600 hp kit at nearly $10,000 USD. He didn't mention what all was in it, but he did say it was complete. For that price, I certainly hope so...

Warren
08-03-2004, 10:15 AM
I'm an LS series owner and I don't wish for any part of the mustang
Then You're a fool blinded by brand loyalty.
Lets not get into this ok? This is a discussion about Whipple, is it not?

miamio
08-03-2004, 09:14 PM
A OK Warren!

AMRAAM4
08-04-2004, 10:37 AM
As for why FI is not for everyone. The real talent in motor design is NA power, with emissions legality, and gas mileage. You can boost anything but i respect raw hp more. Just IMO.

I'm sorry, but that is an ignorant statement from anyone who appreciates modern vehicle performance. My GTO and my 94 RX7 are both fast, edge to the RX7 because of mods and tuning. However, if you are gonna sit here and tell me the twin turbo setup, accompanying mods, and skill it takes to tune that engine is not as "talented" as "raw HP", then maybe you should take up tuning turbocharged cars let alone rotaries. There are about 5 solid tuners in THE WHOLE U.S.A. that can tune that car. And the twin turbo setup in that car and others are nightmares do to the mess of vacuum lines, solenoids, possible boost leaks, actuator valves, charge relief valve, etc. etc. Much more complicated than a 5.7/6.0 V8 engine in your bay. In fact, there are a few RX7's that have done an LS1 swap because it makes life easier.

Now, if you simply want to say you enjoy the workings and sound of a NA pushrod and it's HP, fine, but to say what you did...in the manner you did...is laughable.

Warren
08-04-2004, 10:48 AM
I thought that simplicity was the point, not how hard it is. Ok, I will shutup now.

Tails
08-04-2004, 11:41 AM
I thought that simplicity was the point, not how hard it is. Ok, I will shutup now.
I guess we are just simple minded.
:drink::drink:

gto_in_nc
08-04-2004, 11:47 AM
I guess we are just simple minded.
:drink::drink:

I think you lost me. Now I'm confused. Maybe I just need an AOL account? They've got those nice keyword thingees, ya know?

Screwed Goat
08-04-2004, 05:33 PM
Manufac. dont just put a blower on anything. If it does happen it will be on a rebuilt ls2. A lower compression, stronger rods, pistons, valves ect....


I call BS. GM wouldnt put one on an LS1 or LS2, they might but it on a truck motor with a lower compression ratio. Anyways, If they did supercharge a motor they would most likely use an eaton blower. Whipple would be all over that. The big dawg upgrade for 03/04 cobras is a KB or a Whipple.

Screwed Goat
08-04-2004, 05:35 PM
Starr performance, the makers of the twin screw kit told me they could get me the complete 3.3L twin screw kit w/ maf delete, IC, ect... for 8500 bucks shipped w/ duty tax.

There are a few places in Australia that are just now experimenting with an LSx supercharger kit using a twin screw Whipple-type blower. The one guy I got an email from priced his 600 hp kit at nearly $10,000 USD. He didn't mention what all was in it, but he did say it was complete. For that price, I certainly hope so...

Raxstone
08-09-2004, 09:43 AM
I'm sorry, but that is an ignorant statement from anyone who appreciates modern vehicle performance. My GTO and my 94 RX7 are both fast, edge to the RX7 because of mods and tuning. However, if you are gonna sit here and tell me the twin turbo setup, accompanying mods, and skill it takes to tune that engine is not as "talented" as "raw HP", then maybe you should take up tuning turbocharged cars let alone rotaries. There are about 5 solid tuners in THE WHOLE U.S.A. that can tune that car. And the twin turbo setup in that car and others are nightmares do to the mess of vacuum lines, solenoids, possible boost leaks, actuator valves, charge relief valve, etc. etc. Much more complicated than a 5.7/6.0 V8 engine in your bay. In fact, there are a few RX7's that have done an LS1 swap because it makes life easier.

Now, if you simply want to say you enjoy the workings and sound of a NA pushrod and it's HP, fine, but to say what you did...in the manner you did...is laughable.

You misread what he stated. He stated that the development of the engine itself is where the art is. If you don't have a very well designed engine to start with, there is NO way you are going to end up with a good boosted engine, no matter how talented the booster technician is. That is why a modern engine (pushrod or OHC) is so much more effective boosted than a first gen small block. Technology for both engines is lightyears ahead of where they were 20 years ago. There really is no reason to go off thinking that the OHC is more advanced, when really the pushrod has made huge leaps in technology and development as well. If you want the most efficient THEORETICAL design, then you want the rotary -- not an OHC multivalve engine. Truth is though, engines show how well they are designed when you hit the go pedal, not when you analyze blue prints.

Dbluegoat
08-09-2004, 06:35 PM
Starr performance, the makers of the twin screw kit told me they could get me the complete 3.3L twin screw kit w/ maf delete, IC, ect... for 8500 bucks shipped w/ duty tax.
and this is a direct fit for our goats? what kind of rwhp are we talking?

stonebreaker
08-09-2004, 07:00 PM
Starr performance, the makers of the twin screw kit told me they could get me the complete 3.3L twin screw kit w/ maf delete, IC, ect... for 8500 bucks shipped w/ duty tax.

Dang, He's dropping his price!

'91 Formula
08-10-2004, 04:19 AM
Then You're a fool blinded by brand loyalty.

How is that M3? :sneaky:

http://www.ls2gto.com/forums/showthread.php?t=5064

Warren
08-10-2004, 04:24 AM
A OK Warren!
:D :sneaky: :secret: Lets keep it under control.

whipplegto
08-12-2004, 04:36 AM
and this is a direct fit for our goats? what kind of rwhp are we talking?

A 3.3L whipple in Australia with intercooler, heads & cam was running around 455rwkw (610rwhp) and 10.35@138mph. Currently fastest LS1 GTO in Oz.

Dbluegoat
08-12-2004, 07:42 PM
A 3.3L whipple in Australia with intercooler, heads & cam was running around 455rwkw (610rwhp) and 10.35@138mph. Currently fastest LS1 GTO in Oz.
WOW :cool: :hail:

ok so how much money are we talking??

whipplegto
08-12-2004, 09:46 PM
WOW :cool: :hail:

ok so how much money are we talking??

All-up, including slicks, trans, diff, forged bottom end, fuel system exhaust, blower, intercooler, head & cam, not to mention all the R&D testing etc, maybe another GTO worth of gear, probably more at retail prices. Are you still standing? :cry: He drives it on the street too (not with slicks though :) ).

Dbluegoat
08-13-2004, 04:42 PM
Are you still standing? :cry:.


:banghead: no

Screwed Goat
08-16-2004, 05:33 PM
I wonder if a whipple head unit will bolt up to the Magnusson intake manifold?