This week in the northeast we had a cold spell, and when I most needed cold cranking power, I was let down by the pinnacles of AGM tech, both of them.
Because I'm a dumbass with faith, I ran my Cub Cadet garden tractor on "V-Twin" Mobil1 20W50 this summer, but neglected to change the oil in advance of the winter season. That's the principal dumbass part. But still, 20W isn't "really that bad" for cold weather, you would think. So when it came time to start the tractor in 5°F weather, the little onboard battery had a lot of trouble and could not start the engine.
Ha Ha LOL!
I have an Optima(tm) Yellowtop out of the GTO, *and* a Sears Diehard née Odyssey in the house, I'll just go and get the GTO battery and hook it up in parallel, and life will be groovy, I was thinking.
Not. Optima batteries, IMO, are the biggest marketing sham in the history of the automotive business. Weaksauce, unreliable, POS batteries in a cute little plastic molded 6-pack package that cost $200. Optima-sponsored race events should force all competitors to bump start their cars, for truth in advertising.
I've had two Optima Yellow Tops in the GTO, and both were giant pieces of shit. The first was warranty-denied. YMMV. IMO, "Do Not Buy".
Evidently the 7 or 10 days sitting in the car before I disconnected it was enough to discharge the Deep Discharge battery to a state of discharge insufficient to start a 600cc engine. Yes, I should have left it on a tender in the basement, but damn, not like we're starting a tanker ship ... only a wee little tractor.
Soooooo ... OK, time to take out the flagship, a 35 frame Marine DieHard which is purportedly made by Odyssey. This was sitting in the basement since about October, no tender once again but surely has enough jam to crank a Briggs 600cc 2-cyl, right? Nope. Same sad story.
Admittedly since I repowered with a new Briggs motor, it's a little hard starting, but to only get ~90 seconds of cranking out of a 35 frame Odyssey in cold weather was surprising, too. Could not drive a vehicle to the tractor location without risk of getting stuck due to the snow volume, (Y rated trucks FTW) and my jumper cables aren't 16ft long.
So hooked up all the AGM batteries plus the tractor lead-acid in parallel and left them on 20A charge for 24h. Next day, instead of 5°F it was 15°F and with a bit of ether spray and small fires in the airbox, got it fired up. Win, for the win. Plowed the drive so Track Rated Jeep could get through the snow.
So instead of this being a notransformers kind of thread maligning new tech in general because I hate progress, this is a Wang kind of thread in an advisory role, to suggest that unless you need an AGM battery for weight reduction or nutswinging ... stick with the highest cap lead-acid battery that fits.
Usually, this is a Bosch brand battery, sold at Pep Boys. Got two of those, and they don't discharge in 2 weeks but rather 2+ months unattended, just as my stock GTO battery did when it was new.
Conclusion/cliffs: AGM batteries are shit, do not buy(*)
And yes, thank you, I did change the oil after this joy to Pennzoil 5W30 Synthetic I got on sale at the Vatozone while at the Dragon.
And as a side note of 8Ball-esque karma/hatred, the douchebag that fitted the quick release oil drain fitting at the Japanese factory, to my brand new Briggs Vanguard 23HP, only put it on hand tight, and it was a time bomb waiting to fall out and release all the crankcase oil.
The GTO loves to drain batteries. I would still have my Red Top if I didn't put it on a charger and forget about it for a few hours until I started to smell the thing cooking.
Otherwise, the Red Top worked like a charm. I didn't even put it on a tender for winter storage. She was a jump away from firing right up in the spring.
I didn't go with another Red Top because I was reading on how the newer Optimas were sucking hard. When I picked mine up back in 2007, no store carried them in my area. They could get them, but they had to be special ordered. It seems like the quality went downward when every chain parts store began to carry them.
Probably had to do with the corporate chains wanting xx amount of batteries but only wanted to pay xx amount of dollars. Fine. Switch to cheaper manufacturing practices, let the quality slip, and ride the name for a few years until word gets around that the batteries suck. By then, everyone who made their fortune will have jumped ship and left someone else to try and save the product's face.
As soon as I get to work and as soon as I get home my goat gets plugged into a battery tender. My AGM battery works fine
Yeah, that's the point. As long as you babysit the little cripple batteries, they are at least 1/4 as good as normal lead acid batteries.
When my GTO was new I could leave it for a month or 6 weeks in the winter on the stock battery, go out, and it was a little sluggish to start, but did. My van sits out there with a security system and a Bosch battery, no problem after a month. Jeep's Bosch is the size of an 18-pak of beer, it sat for 3 months for want of tires last spring, and no problemo, VROOOOOOOooom.
I'm not sold anymore on AGM frankly, especially when I took the Diehard Marine out there and it was meh. Like I want to be out on the water and for 2# of weight savings, have to page the Coast Guard.
I had a yellowtop develop bad cells after a disappointingly short time and only a couple of discharge events. A deep cycle battery you can't deep cycle. What a concept. Went back to Duralast Gold and haven't looked back. For me, it was a huge waste of $.
Duralast Gold here, too, since last year. FWIW, I had a Braille AGM that lasted the better part of three years. It did not like cold weather or the GTO parasitic drain. The last two winters I had to put the battery on a tender at least once a week. It was a tiny battery, though.
My red top has been fine for 4 years, but I keep a tender on it. The reason I keep a tender on it is because my first one was toast after leaving it for a few months in the winter. So this one is a warranty replacement. I don't consider such a high maintenance battery, a "good" battery. When it finally craps out, I'll probably replace it with a regular battery.
Sears Diehard Platinum, same thing is as the Odyssey at half the price and has a 4 year full replacement with 100 month pro-rated warranty. It's around the same price as the POS optima too. It's the last battery you will buy with it's warranty period. Parasitic power draw will kill any battery as well.
My yellowtop is a warranty replacement. Same story here too, Wang. Leave that litte smurfer unattended for a couple weeks and it will die. Let it die 3 or 4 times and it will be gone forever. Got a tender for this second one. Next battery will be a Vatazone gold. Have one of those in all the other cars. Never dead, and some of those shits sit outside for month or two on end with no attention. I guess Goats do eat anthing and everything, including their own battery.
Originally Posted by wrp...
....Guy did offer to throw in his wife. I turned her down, no man should be without his personal critic to tell him everything he says and does is wrong
Billet Pro Shifter, SCSS Pod w/oil/volt, Kooks 1 7/8 LT, catted mids, SS 3" catback, SCSS mounts, Harrop rear cover, Hotchkiss Sways, BC Racing ER, with 9k,10k springs, poly bushings, BMR skid plate, SFC, and STB, JHP lip v2, SLP Predator, Pedders Fast Rack. Installing: SNL Blower cam, Harrop HTV2300, Willwood 14" BBK
Wow. I don't know what kind of cars you guys drive that drain the battery so bad, but when I got my GTO I replaced the battery like three weeks later with a cheapo one from Pep-Boys. About a year later we got 3 ft. of snow and I let the GTO sit outside without moving for almost two months. I had heard that these cars were hard on batteries so I went to go drive the car around and charge the battery up. It fired right up. I let that car sit all the time and never had a single issue.
RIP - Sgt. James E. Lyons. Apache Company Senior Sniper, 1st 1FT Squadron, 2nd Stryker Cavalry Regiment. Aug 13th, 1987 - Sept 12th, 2011 - KIA.
Wow. I don't know what kind of cars you guys drive but when I got my GTO I replaced the battery like three weeks later with a cheapo one from Pep-Boys. About a year later we got 3 ft. of snow and I let the GTO sit outside without moving for almost two months. I had heard that these cars were hard on batteries so I went to go drive the car around and charge the battery up. It fired right up. I let that car sit all the time and never had a single issue.
I work in auto parts and just from customers experience the Optima's are hit and miss. Its either you get one that works great and as advertised for years, or you get one that just sucks and last 2 months or less. Cherrys or lemons no gray area there.
I've had my red top so long I can't even remember when I got it. Still works like a champ even in this cold weather. One of the best I have owned.
I will say as great as my red top is (knock on wood), and as odd is it sounds...the absolute best battery I have ever owned was a Everstart MAXX (yellow style 1000CA/850CCA). Most ppl hate Walmart jobs, but it has taken 4 years of steady high amp stereo punsihment and cold weather. I could not phase that thing. It would crank for days. It's been in 3 different vehicles and the guy that bought my truck still has it today, almost 8 years old.
I don't know why the problems, my red top is 5 years old and died the first winter I forgot to tender it. Connected the tender and charged it up and it's been running fine since.
2005 Midnight Blue Metallic M6
Magnuson TVS 1900 Kroma Kote 553 rwhp 522 torque 8.5 lbs. boost. Ed Curtis custom cam
JBA Headers and JBA high flow catted mids H pipe Magnaflow Catback GMM Street LPE CAI
TSW Chrome Nogaro Wheels with Michelin Pilot Super Sport Tires
18x8 front / 18x9 rear 245/40 front 275/35 rear
2007 Pontiac G6 GT (winter car)
First car 1968 GTO 4 speed Mayfair Maize 6.5
I let my yellow top go dead as a hammer and I will jump it off and it is good as new. I just recently started putting a battery tender on it. I would have went through a bunch of standard batteries the way I neglect them. Mine has served me well so far for 3 or 4 years now.
Had the stocker and won a new red top at a GTO event in 2007. Swapped out and within two weeks the battery failed. The event host gave me an interstate replacement that worked great for about 4 years. Got a new red top for free last year. When I get a chance she's going in the dumpster. If I leave it any longer than 2 weeks unattended its dead. Wang your on the money, great marketing piss poor product.
I put a Diehard Platinum in my Gto in 2009.
My Saab is ridiculously hard on batteries.
After two Duralasts in three years in the Saab, this fall, I bought a new Platinum for the Gto, put that Platinum in my 07 Silverado and put the Silverado's original Delco in the Saab.
My Gto sits in an unheated garage for weeks at a clip in the winter and I've never had a problem with the Platinums.
The four year old Platinum hasn't had any problems starting my Siverado even after sitting days in the single digit weather.
My Saab is dead in the driveway with the Delco after sitting one night in the cold.
The Saab is 10X harder on batteries than my Gto.
My friend's 2002 F-150 is still on it's original battery.
For the last few winters I've been telling him it's gonna die and leave him stranded but that fu€&ing thing won't die.
The AutoGuide.com network consists of the largest network of enthusiast-owned enthusiast-operated automotive communities.
AutoGuide.com provides the latest car reviews, auto show coverage, new car prices, and automotive news. The AutoGuide network operates more than 100 automotive forums where our users consult peers for shopping information and advice, and share opinions as a community.